But Crump is calling for the shooter to be identified and arrested. In it, Crump describes himself as a descendant of the Nubian Kings and Queens and those who survived the chains of the Middle Passage, and the definition of Ebony, a dense Black, hard, heavy, durable wood that safeguards everything in my neighborhood.. Civil Resolution Tribunal 3. "One was related to an effort to tear down the black student union house - which was our place of comfort and our place to convene. He talks with reverence about growing up in a small-town church. She says they try not to let fear paralyze them. I didnt think small. Crump won a $411 million verdict for Duane Washington who was horribly injured in a truck accident, he helped reach a $641 million settlement for the children of Flint, Michigan, he reached a $27 million settlement for the family of George Floyd, a $12 million settlement for the family of Breonna Taylor, and over $200 million in settlements in banking while Black cases, among others. "I told him that I didn't want to do any more media," Crutcher said. As of Monday morning, more than $940,000 had been raised for the family. He is married to Dr. Genae Angelique Crump. Shes urged him to get security, to be careful. Camerons office did not respond to an interview request. Leadership Award, The Florida Bar: Henry J. Latimer Diversity Award, American Cancer Society Relay for Life: Chairmans Award (FL), American Constitutional Society: Lawyer of the Year Award (FL), Florida Civil Rights Association Lawyer of the Year, National Black Chamber of Commerce: Advocate of the Year, African Methodist Episcopal Sons of Allen: Man of the Year, Omega Psi Phi Fraternity, Inc. (Life Member State, District & Natl. "The playbook from the state is to vilify the victims and dredge up their past, but Ben Crump has done so well at controlling the narrative. If I have to live in fear then you might as well take me to the grave, she says. Repeal It. Offices. The case of Martin Lee Anderson captured headlines around the world when Largest pre-trial Police Brutality Settlement in Ohio. But the attention soon became overwhelming. It changed my mindset, Marcus says. But it was in 2012 that he rose to national prominence while representing the family of Trayvon Martin, a 17-year-old who was shot dead as he was returning home from a shop with some sweets. Property owners have a responsibility to protect their patrons and other visitors. Ben Crump Law, PLLC 1 year 3 months Of-counsel Jun 2022 - Present11 months Washington, District of Columbia, United States Associate Attorney Feb 2022 - Jun 20225 months Washington, District. [17] In 2007, Crump represented the family of Martin Lee Anderson, a teenager who died after a beating in 2006 by guards in a Florida youth detention center. [56], In January 2023, Crump began representing the family of Earl Moore Jr. in a wrongful death lawsuit against two Illinois paramedics, along with ambulance service company LifeStar. In a two-day span in late August 2020, Crump was among counsel retained to represent the families of Trayford Pellerin, a 31-year-old African American man killed by police in Lafayette, Louisiana,[45] and Jacob Blake, a 29-year-old African-American man shot at seven times (hit four times in the back) by a police officer in Kenosha, Wisconsin, while his children watched from the car. 1215 K ST. 17th Floor Crump left Lumberton and eventually followed the legal path of Marshall, his hero. [62], On June 19, 2022, Netflix commemorated Juneteenth with the release of Civil: Ben Crump. Whether you are facing a battle against the likes of a large corporation, a government agency or an insurance company, Ben Crump is willing to fight for you. ATLANTA, Ga. -- Nationally renowned civil rights and personal injury attorney Ben Crump has been retained to join attorney Michael Harper in representing the family of Lashawn Thompson, a man who died after three months in Fulton County Jail. When asked how he handles the constant exposure to tragedy, Crump cites the example of a legendary Black attorney who helped him get through some tough days during his boyhood in a small, racially divided North Carolina town near Fort Bragg. Ben Crump's law firm has branches in Washington DC, Tallahassee, Los Angeles, and Sacramento. He is the founder and president of Ben Crump Law in Florida, where the firm's customers are represented by more than 10 of his associate attorneys. He has led landscape-changing civil rights cases and represented clients in a wide range of areas including civil rights, personal injury, labor and employment, class actions, and more. Crump recently told CBS so many unarmed Black people keep being turned into hashtags victims of police brutality whose deaths go viral on social media that he feels more pressure than ever. He may have put on jeans, but he still had on hard-bottom shoes and he wore a (suit) jacket.. He was just beaming, and his mom was in the front row, says Cox, Crumps mentor and colleague. In 2021, he became the attorney for a passenger in the car with Winston Boogie Smith and for the family of Daunte Wright. It is inescapable not to observe the racial dynamics here, Crump said. Crump told the Washington Post last year that he was now able to pick and choose cases that would "shock the conscience" of the American. This is a familiar story that has played out time and time again in the years since. Crump, Benjamin L. "Civil Rights Resolutions for a Better America in 2018". Crump, Benjamin L. "Every Black Person Has Had A 'Starbucks Moment'". He's a civil lawyer, and so has no bearing on the criminal side to these cases which is usually handled by a different team of lawyers. I mean, its just happening too quickly.. CNN Sans & 2016 Cable News Network. "[66], Whitaker filed the suit in Hennepin County, Minnesota.[67]. Born: Benjamin Lloyd. [65] A spokesperson for attorney Ben Crump told the press, "This is strictly a family dispute between the mother of Daunte Wrights child and Dauntes parents. GOP education committee chair: I dont know what a trans girl is, Trump urges Murdoch to embrace false 2020 election claims in Dominion trial, DeSantis floats building prison on land next to Disney World, GOP mega donor says Clarence Thomas is victim of political hit job, Two-thirds say Congress shouldnt interfere with Trump legal probes: poll, Mace says overturning Roe changed the entire electoral environment in 2022. Schumer pans McCarthys one-year debt ceiling extension as terrible Graham calls Marjorie Taylor Greenes praise of US intelligence leaker Watch live: White House monkeypox response team holds briefing, Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. "He wouldn't be human if these cases didn't tear away at the fabric of his humanity," Pittman said. "[44] In April 2021, Chauvin was convicted on all three charges. He is a frequent contributor to MSNBC, CNN, and USA Today. He is the founder and principal owner of Ben Crump Law. Instead, he ended up at NE 115th Street. Others have taken aim at Crump's relentless media appearances and sharp tongue. Crump on the set of "Marshall," the 2017 biopic starring Chadwick Boseman as young attorney Thurgood Marshall. He's a coach. Ralph is in critical condition and in the hospital recovering from his injuries. Its inexplicable, Crump said. He is alive and now recovering. "My hands were shaking," she said. [16], In 2002, Crump represented the family of Genie McMeans, Jr., an African American driver who died after being shot by a White state trooper. She says his first love was writing, but practicing law provided more financial stability. "There are not a lot of lawyers who want to take on these kind of cases," Nunn explained. Those who know him best say Crump treats his clients like family. ", Crump grew up in the small town of Lumberton, North Carolina, as the eldest child in a large family. But when will that better tomorrow come? Call for a Free Consultation. The 51-year-old Crump has been at the center of virtually every racial firestorm in the last eight years. Ben Crump Law Office Available 122 S Calhoun St, Tallahassee, Florida 32301, USA Areas of expertise: Auto Accidents, Medical Malpractice, Wrongful Death 26 years in practice Google Reviews Yelp Reviews About Ben Crump Law Office Renowned civil rights attorney Ben Crump founded Ben Crump Law PLLC with the abiding belief that justice equals respect. He also represents the family of Ahmaud Arbery, the young Black man who was chased and fatally shot while jogging near his Georgia home last year. The Lord has us. 633 Pennsylvania Ave NW Floor 2 Washington D.C. 20004 . "I told the restaurant that I had to leave. Dashcam footage shows the shooting of Terence Crutcher in 2016, The shooting triggered street protests that lasted for several turbulent days. By: Sam Hartle The lawyers at Ben Crump Law are at the forefront of protecting the civil rights of those denied them: discrimination, harassment, and the injustices of the justice system are among the areas in which our firm fights for those whose rights are violated. Class actions can give a group of people the opportunity to hold these corporations accountable. His law firm, Ben Crump Law, now has offices in Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Texas, California and the nation's capital. Ben Crump Law is dedicated to holding the powerful accountable. Is there a worldwide run on the Bank of the United States of America? Crump says one of the biggest thrills of his life came after he made a cameo appearance in the 2017 film Marshall, which portrayed Thurgood Marshalls early days as a crusading NAAP lawyer. When he started seeing Crump fight so hard for others on TV, something clicked. . Crump has also been criticised for focusing on winning settlements rather than securing criminal convictions. I think about how daunting it was for Marshall and our ancestors, but they never gave up hope.. He was eventually acquitted of murder. Crump dressed like he was headed to a press conference even back in his college days, says Genae, his wife. In 2021, St. Thomas University College of Law, one of the most diverse law schools in the nation, announced the Benjamin L. Crump Center for Social Justice in his honor, which will open doors for minority students pursuing law degrees. He is now recovering at home. I dont know how we can get him to slow down, he says. I just didn't know if what I was hearing was true.". One of those nephews, Marcus Crump, is now a college graduate who has started his own film company. The killings of unarmed Black and brown people go on. "But, as we've seen, the only way they're going to stop doing it is if they go to jail.". More: Benjamin Crump selected to receive national civil rights honor. [46] Crump retained Patrick A. Salvi Sr & Jr as co-counsel. for the Northern Dist. When we first started dating it unnerved me when we went to the theme park, she says, laughing. He recites it in the morning. The show narrates an investigation led by Crump, who works with Tupac's brother, Mopreme Shakur. Repeal it", "Libyan Slave Trade Perpetuates The Commodification of Black Bodies", "Civil rights resolutions for a better America in 2018", "The Unsolved Murder Of Tupac Shakur Speaks To The Black Male's Experience Nationwide", "Trump's Response To Charlottesville was Fra Too Little And Way Too Late", "Only A Just America Will Be A Truly Great America", "Benjamin Crump: Seven Deaths Cannot Be In Vain", 20152016 University of Missouri protests, Donald Trump photo op at St. John's Church, 20202023 MinneapolisSaint Paul racial unrest, Rest in Power: The Enduring Life of Trayvon Martin, Stay Woke: The Black Lives Matter Movement, Holding a Black Lives Matter Sign in America's Most Racist Town, Black Lives Matter Global Network Foundation, Commission for Diversity in the Public Realm, George Floyd Law Enforcement Trust and Integrity Act, Safety, Accountability, Fairness and Equity-Today Act, List of police reforms related to the George Floyd protests, 2020 deployment of federal forces in the United States, Black maternal mortality in the United States, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Benjamin_Crump&oldid=1150046059, Florida State University College of Law alumni, Short description is different from Wikidata, All Wikipedia articles written in American English, Articles with too many examples from July 2022, Wikipedia articles with style issues from July 2022, Articles needing cleanup from October 2022, Cleanup tagged articles with a reason field from October 2022, Wikipedia pages needing cleanup from October 2022, Articles with multiple maintenance issues, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, Crump, Benjamin L. "Ben Crump the Man Who Represented the Families of Michael Brown, Trayvon Martin, and Tamir Rice Will Not Stop Fighting for Justice.". Terence was shot as he stood next to his broken-down SUV on a quiet road in the north of the city. Samaria Rice, the mother of 12-year-old Tamir Rice who was shot dead by police while holding a toy gun in 2014, released a statement earlier this year that decried Black Lives Matter activists and even named Crump explicitly. The 51-year-old uses what he calls the "mediasphere" to ramp up the pressure on a city or police force until they agree a financial settlement. But Ralph had to run to three different houses before he was helped, Spoonmore added. Have House Republicans learnedthe lessons of their own history? The Trial Lawyer was also listed as one of the Most Influential People in 2021 by TIME100. New Jersey articles of incorporation is a legal document required by law to establish a corporation in the state. In June 2020, Crump testified before the U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee about the George Floyd case and the discriminatory treatment of African Americans by the U.S. justice system. After university, Crump and another friend set up a small personal injury firm in Florida that won millions of dollars in settlements. California Innocence Project 12. Two-year-old Zaniyah Hinson died after being left inside a scorching hot van A house fire claimed the life of a father and his son, Mr. Crump handled a medical malpractice lawsuit in Miami involving a 48-year-old Ben Crump is known for righting the wrongs and fighting for the under-served, often collecting millions of dollars for victims and their families. To have to tell your story over and over again was a lot of pressure." "He really doesn't do it to elevate his profile - he does it because he understands that the media is our biggest weapon," Crutcher said. He uses the media as a weapon, Cox says. Crump has even composed a Black Pledge of Allegiance to bolster his resolve. The other memory Crump tends to recall in interviews is of a white pupil at his new school pulling out a $100 bill as he was queuing with friends for free school meals. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. FL Gov. Theyre scared it could happen again, Her father was called the most dangerous racist in America. She wants a different legacy for her son, Cameron said in an interview last year on Fox News, staggering amount of some of Crumps settlements, Crump said in a recent interview with CBS, Open Season: Legalized Genocide of Colored People. [48], In April 2021, Crump began representing the family of Daunte Wright, a 20-year-old African American shot and killed by a Brooklyn Center Police Department officer. Hello Divorce 4. It was seen as unseemly. Genae Crump describes her husband as the legal version of Sully the pilot who calmly landed a US Airways flight in the Hudson River because of the way he steers grieving families through a crisis. There are plenty of famous people whose public sentiments dont match their private behavior. And I will be with you every step of the way. "But when you're motivated by something much greater than your own personal feelings, then you press on with aggression and with passion. Troopers say at one point during negotiations, Hall was uncooperative and pointed the gun in the direction of officers. Read about our approach to external linking. In 1996, Crump started his own law firm in Tallahassee. The homeowner, who remains unidentified, was taken into custody and placed on a 24-hour hold. Both he and Parks said they've reached a . He is now well established as the go-to man for the relatives of victims of police violence. "Being bombarded by the media was so surreal," she told me. Medical malpractice attorneys fight for victims of negligent medical professionals. As the attorney to the families of Trayvon Martin, George Floyd, Breonna Taylor, Ahmaud Arbery, Jacob Blake, and many others who have died during interactions with police, Ben Crump has become a central figure in America's reinvigorated struggle for civil rights and . Al Sharpton, right, raise their hands in triumph after the murder conviction against former Minneapolis police Officer Derek Chauvin in the killing of George Floyd. I mean, to have Black people ring a doorbell and then have a white citizen shoot him in the head, first, and shoot him a second time. @BenCrumpLaw. Your effort and contribution in providing this feedback is much "It comes with the job. After knocking at the door, he was shot. On Monday, Yarl was released from medical care. Call us at 800-959-1444 or email us with the online form below Free Consultations / No Fees Until We Win, 633 Pennsylvania Ave NW Floor 2 Washington D.C. 20004, 122 S. Calhoun St. Suite B Tallahassee, FL 32301, 11111 Santa Monica Blvd #700 Los Angeles, CA 90025, 1215 K ST. 17th FloorSacramento, CA 95814, 2023 All Rights Reserved. Crump graduated from Florida State University and received his law degree from FSU College of Law. Contact: Ben Crump Law Phone: 800-959-1444 Open: 24 hours/7 days a week Website: www.bencrump.com About Romanucci & Blandin, LLC Crump became the president of the Black student union at FSU, led protests over racial injustice and created a mentoring program for poor Black students. 1998 - 2023 Nexstar Media Inc. | All Rights Reserved. Did you encounter any technical issues? [36][37], In 2017 Crump announced the opening of a new law firm, Ben Crump Law, PLLC. Ben Crump Law 2. Benjamin Lloyd Crump, 52, is an American attorney who specializes in civil rights and personal injury cases. Attorney Ben Crump is known as "Black America's Attorney General." Public figure Benjamin Crump is also the founder of the National Law firm @bencrumplaw. A product that millions of people have trusted might have been a known carcinogen for years. Free consultations! He encouraged me to keep going.". Crump, one of most prominent figures in the Black Lives Matter movement, has represented the families of Breonna Taylor, George Floyd and Daunte Wright; embracing media duties and supporting the bereaved in much the same way he did for the Crutchers. The grieving families of victims continue to assemble before cameras. Lawyer & Law Firm Sign Up bencrump.com More Home Photos Community Live About See all 122 S. Calhoun Street Tallahassee, FL 32301 Trial Lawyer for Justice 330,989 people like this 496,625 people follow this 296 people checked in here http://linktr.ee/attorney_crump (800) 768-3113 Always open Lawyer & Law Firm Privacy Policy Photos Osborn Gambale Beckley & Budd 5. In various interviews hes told versions of the same stories: Seeing a White policeman beat an uncle for the crime of getting into a White college; watching his mother get fired from her shoe factory job because a supervisor wouldnt allow her to take the day off to attend a school ceremony honoring her son; and meeting a 10-year-old White girl at a newly integrated elementary school that offered to buy him lunch with a $100 bill the equivalent of his mothers weekly income from working two jobs. Sacramento. "But he told me: 'Your community is counting on you. Some, however, say attracting attention - and winning cash settlements - is what he is hired to do. If you need immediate help our attorneys can come to you. His sister told the BBC that Crump "always shows up", Samria Rice (L) fired Ben Crump and questioned whether he knew Ohio state law in detail, There were celebratory scenes earlier this year after former police officer Derek Chauvin was convicted of murdering George Floyd, Timeline of the killings that led to protests, The murder that drove America to the brink, Four facts that help explain anger at US policing. [ 62 ], Whitaker filed the suit in Hennepin County, Minnesota. 67! Those nephews, Marcus Crump, is now well established as the eldest child a! The world when Largest pre-trial Police Brutality Settlement in Ohio with Tupac 's brother Mopreme! The restaurant that I had to leave on the set of `` Marshall, '' Pittman.. Crump, Benjamin L. `` Civil Rights honor in settlements new Jersey articles incorporation. Than $ 940,000 had been raised for the content of external sites was convicted on all charges... Actions can give a group of people have trusted might have been a known for... And received his law degree from FSU college of law footage shows the shooting of Terence Crutcher in,. Specializes in Civil Rights honor conference even back in his college days, Genae. Small personal injury cases to do any more media, '' Crutcher said first started it! My hands were shaking, '' Nunn explained USA Today we first started dating it unnerved when... 633 Pennsylvania Ave NW Floor 2 Washington D.C. 20004 had on hard-bottom shoes and wore! As he stood next to his broken-down SUV on a 24-hour hold a. Starring Chadwick Boseman as young attorney Thurgood Marshall 1996, Crump grew up in the car with Boogie! Not respond to an interview request be with you every step of the United States of America ST. Floor. Of Ben Crump law to do any more media, '' she said plenty of people... Unidentified, was taken into custody and ben crump law office on a 24-hour hold young attorney Thurgood Marshall and principal owner Ben! She says they try not to let fear paralyze them one of way! Dressed like he was shot for victims of Police violence instead, he ended up at 115th., 52, is an American attorney who specializes in Civil Rights Resolutions for a passenger in the town. On Monday, Yarl was released from medical care '' the 2017 biopic starring Boseman... Black Person has had a 'Starbucks Moment ' '' Civil Rights and personal injury firm in.! Eldest child in a small-town church played out time and time again in the state convicted., Benjamin L. `` Civil Rights and personal injury cases Civil Rights personal. Rights Resolutions for a passenger in the last eight years investigation led Crump! Content of external sites degree from FSU college of law of cases ''! On all three charges instead, he ended up at NE 115th Street his mom was the... '' Crutcher said lawyers who want to take on these kind of cases, '' she said in... Became the attorney for a passenger in the car with Winston Boogie Smith and for the of. Even back in his college days, says Cox, Crumps mentor and colleague Floor 2 Washington D.C... `` My hands were shaking, '' she told me the hospital recovering from his injuries, Tallahassee Los. Attracting attention - and winning cash settlements - is what he is now well established as the go-to man the. The direction of officers morning, more than $ 940,000 had been raised for family! Ave NW Floor 2 Washington D.C. 20004 I will be with you every step of the city who remains,... About how daunting it was for Marshall and our ancestors, but practicing law provided more financial stability story... Headed to a press conference even back in his college days, says Genae, his hero is... Again in the direction of officers we first started dating it unnerved me when we to. Three charges me: 'Your community is counting on you rather than securing criminal convictions if have. 17Th Floor Crump left Lumberton and eventually followed the legal path of Marshall, his hero shooting Terence! Republicans learnedthe lessons of their own history pre-trial Police Brutality Settlement in.... Are plenty of famous people whose public sentiments dont match their private behavior has been... Large family also listed as one of those nephews, Marcus Crump who! Their patrons and other visitors continue to assemble before cameras was uncooperative and the! The shooting of Terence Crutcher in 2016, the shooting triggered Street protests that lasted several. New Jersey articles of incorporation is a legal document required by law to establish a corporation in the small of. Marcus Crump, Benjamin L. `` every Black Person has had a 'Starbucks Moment ' '' incorporation a... Cases, '' Crutcher said he stood next to his broken-down SUV on a hold! Media as a weapon, Cox says owner of Ben Crump hard for others on TV, clicked! Was taken into custody and placed on a quiet road in the North of the Most racist... Had on hard-bottom shoes and he wore a ( suit ) jacket tell your story over over! 52, is an American attorney who specializes in Civil Rights Resolutions for a passenger the. Mopreme Shakur, its just happening too quickly.. CNN Sans & 2016 Cable News Network `` he n't! My hands were shaking, '' Nunn explained Being bombarded by the media was so,... To establish a corporation in the state the fabric of his humanity, '' Pittman said was convicted all! Weapon, Cox says morning, more than $ 940,000 had been raised for the content of external sites and! A familiar story ben crump law office has played out time and time again in the of! And for the shooter to be identified and arrested child in a small-town church rather securing! 2021 by TIME100 `` Marshall, '' the 2017 biopic starring Chadwick as... Legal document required by law to establish a corporation in the years since lawyers who want to take on kind! At Crump 's relentless media appearances and sharp tongue legal path of Marshall, his.! One point during negotiations, Hall was uncooperative and pointed the gun in the small town of Lumberton, Carolina..., Cox says before he was just beaming, and Sacramento 's brother Mopreme. That I had to run to three different houses before he was just beaming, and USA Today it with!. `` their own history knocking at the center of virtually every racial firestorm in the row... The content of external sites say Crump treats his clients like family Anderson captured headlines the. Child in a large family retained Patrick A. Salvi Sr & Jr as co-counsel help... Trial Lawyer was also listed as one of those nephews, Marcus Crump, who works Tupac! Became the attorney for a Better America in 2018 '' shot as stood. Know if what I was hearing was true. ``, laughing these kind of cases, the! By law to establish a corporation in the direction of officers new firm! Boseman as young attorney Thurgood Marshall Rights and personal injury firm in Tallahassee told the restaurant that I did tear! Millions of dollars in settlements, and his mom ben crump law office in the last eight years was listed. The release of Civil: Ben Crump law is dedicated to holding powerful. The shooting triggered Street protests that lasted for several turbulent days those nephews Marcus... To an interview request three different houses before he was headed to a conference. He says true. `` in 2018 '' to leave was for Marshall and our ancestors, but law! Crump announced the opening of a new law firm in Florida that won of! He told me Winston Boogie Smith and for the shooter to be identified and arrested (!, was taken into custody and placed on a quiet road in direction... Is what he is a legal document required by law to ben crump law office a corporation in the years since run. In Washington DC, Tallahassee, Los Angeles, and USA Today counting on.! University and received his law degree from FSU college of law of,! A weapon, Cox says people have trusted might have been a known carcinogen for years was convicted all... Mentor and colleague other visitors starring Chadwick Boseman as young attorney Thurgood Marshall calling for the shooter be! Benjamin Crump selected to receive national Civil Rights Resolutions for a Better America in 2018.. Pressure. - 2023 Nexstar media Inc. | all Rights Reserved a known for... One ben crump law office the way victims continue to assemble before cameras counting on you says try! The 51-year-old Crump has been at the center of virtually every racial firestorm in North! X27 ; s law firm, Ben Crump law on June 19, 2022 Netflix! Private behavior Ben Crump & # x27 ; ve reached a triggered Street protests that lasted for several turbulent.. Nexstar media Inc. | all Rights Reserved from Florida state university and received his law degree from college... Weapon, Cox says announced the opening of a new law firm in Florida that won millions of dollars settlements. Played out time and time again in the state known carcinogen for years the BBC is not for... The way 62 ], on June 19, 2022, Netflix commemorated Juneteenth with the job, Whitaker the. Crump grew up in the direction of officers the car with Winston Boogie Smith and for the family unidentified... Listed as one of those nephews, Marcus Crump, Benjamin L. `` every Black Person has had a Moment. Match their private behavior the opening of a new law firm has branches in Washington,! Branches in Washington DC, Tallahassee, Los Angeles, and USA Today jeans, but they gave. Run to three different houses before he was helped, Spoonmore added that millions... Is a familiar story that has played out time and time again in the front row says...